Skip to main content

Pump Street 58% Madagascar Milk Chocolate Bar Review

Disclosure: This article may contain affiliate links (identified by a ° symbol). These financially support this website - and our chocolate research - at no extra cost to you. Find out more.

It's no secret - I love Pump Street's chocolate, especially their bars that fuse the best of their chocolate craft with the best creations from their very own bakery. If you've not come across the brand before, check out their Sourdough & Sea Salt Chocolate, Gingerbread Dark Chocolate, Panettone Dark Chocolate, and Hot Cross Bun Dark Chocolate bars.

Today's bar is my first look at just their chocolate craft. It's a simple 58% dark milk chocolate crafted from cocoa beans sourced from a single estate in Madagascar.


The bar is presented inside the same packaging used elsewhere in the Pump Street range. It's a beige foil-backed paper envelope with a push seal lip. A pink bordered sticker lists the product name at the base of the wrapper, while a pink circular sticker (listing the batch number and best before date) seals the top.

Pump Street 58% Madagascar Milk Chocolate Bar Review
Pump Street 58% Madagascar Milk Chocolate Bar

The cocoa for this single estate chocolate bar heralds from the Åkesson's Organic Estate in Ambanja, northern Madagscar.

The rear of the packaging explores Pump Street's ethics and heritage. It also explains that the resealable envelope and sticker is 100% compostable, designed as part of Pump Street's aim to make their packaging as sustainable and low impact as possible.

A sticker at the bottom lists the ingredients (in English, German and French) and nutritional information for this bar.

Pump Street 58% Madagascar Milk Chocolate Bar ingredients:
Organic cocoa beans, cane sugar, organic cocoa butter, milk powder. Cocoa solids: 58% minimum.

The bar contains a smidgen over 32% sugars. It contains an unusually large amount of cocoa for a milk chocolate bar, which is clearly a very good thing.

Pump Street 58% Madagascar Milk Chocolate Bar Review

A beautiful 16 segment bar awaits inside the envelope. I found four pieces makes a pleasant serving.

It is practically flawless, with a glimmering sheen and a pleasing snap. It's also got a characterful aroma, full of molasses, brown bread, and just a hint of tobacco. In fact, its aroma is more akin to that of a dark chocolate than a milk chocolate.

Pump Street 58% Madagascar Milk Chocolate Bar
16 shimmering segments form this bar

Pump Street describes this chocolate as "creamy and luxurious" (thanks to the inclusion of whole milk) with notes of caramel and treacle, with a zesty finish. For me, I get a very similar picture, but in reverse.

The initial taste is quite fruity, almost zesty, The flavour elegantly morphs throughout the melt. Notes of honey make way for richer, jammy prune notes. It then darts into hints of tangy pineapple before mellowing out in to nutty, cashew-like flavours.

Pump Street 58% Madagascar Milk Chocolate Bar Pieces
Ready to eat!

Buttery flavours develop right at the end, with hints of creamy toffee in the subtle aftertaste. The aftertaste fades gently but quickly.

While delicious, as suspected, it lacks the signature crunch of some creations from Pump Street's bakery. That's not to say this is a bad bar, just simply less exciting than their mashup bars in my opinion.

This chocolate is smooth, elegant and takes you on a journey along gentle waves of flavour. It doesn't thrash you around, nor does it push your boundaries, but instead it demonstrates craftsmanship in the form of bean-to-bar chocolate.

As for the 58% cocoa content, if you're worried this is too intense for you, fear not. The sugar levels and milk powder help to soften the intensity of the cocoa, making a very well balanced and flavourful dark milk chocolate bar.

Pump Street 58% Madagascar Milk Chocolate Bar Review

RRP: £6.75 | Pump Street | Shop now

A sophisticated, indulgent grown-up chocolate bar with the sweetness and creaminess of a milk chocolate but the nuances of a dark chocolate. While it lacks excitement for me, it does demonstrate craftsmanship in creating a flavourful single farm chocolate bar,

Score: 4.4

Where to Buy Online

Pump Street sells this bar directly on its website and in its Bakery in Orford, Suffolk (£6.75). It's also available on speciality websites such as Cocoa Runners (£6.75), Ustudio (£6.75), and Pinney's of Orford (£6.75).

There's also a smaller 20g size available in pink packaging. Halen Môn (£6.20) and The Bay Tree Company (£2.99) stock these. Pump Street sells this bar as a four pack here (£10.40).

Tell Pump Street Chocolate You Saw It On!

Please mention in your order notes when you place an order with Pump Street Chocolate online. It means the world to me, and lets Pump Street Chocolate know helped you decide to make a purchase today. Thank you for your support

What is your favourite Pump Street bar? Let me know in a comment below.

Disclosure: A family member gifted me a 70g Pump Street 58% Madagascar Milk Chocolate Bar. I was not asked for a review. My opinions are my own.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Chocolate books

Chocolate Books on Amazon°

My growing chocolate book library is a testament to the addictive nature of recipe books. My collection of chocolate books spans the history of chocolate, recipes, tales of chocolate makers, and even the science behind chocolate. Amazon has a huge range of chocolate books, ideal as gifts or for research, usually available in print or Kindle formats.

Shop at Amazon°

Get your chocolate shopping delivered faster with a free trial of Amazon Prime. Terms apply; new accounts only. No code needed. Shop at Amazon°

We're not sure when this expires. Terms and exclusions may apply. See website for details.