Skip to main content

Venchi 1878 Pick & Mix Chocolates Review

Disclosure: This article may contain affiliate links (identified by a ° symbol). These financially support this website - and our chocolate research - at no extra cost to you. Find out more.

I'm a big cruise ship fan, and first heard about the Venchi 1878 brand in the build-up to the launch of MSC Cruises' high-tech MSC Seaside cruise ship. Here, the Italian chocolate maker's products took centre stage in the Venchi 1878 Chocolate Bar, set against a backdrop of a curtain of molten chocolate.

This clip from Blog Dos Cruzeiros demonstrates it perfectly.

On a trip to London, I discovered there was a branch of Venchi 1878 nestled away inside Covent Garden. With opening hours running to as late as 11pm, it was the perfect venue for my late night chocolate shopping in the capital.


Venchi 1878 in Covent Garden, London

If you are unfamiliar with Covent Garden, it's an affluent part of town, styled as an Italian-style Piazza and home to high-end fashion stores, award-winning restaurants, and theatres. The historic Covent Garden Market Building opened in 1830 and is home to a selection of shops - most notably for us chocolate lovers, these include Godiva, Hotel Chocolat and Venchi 1878.

Upon first glance, the boutique looked cosy, with a gelato counter doing a brisk trade. There was a shelf of chocolate boxes to one side, along with a small selection of pick-and-mix chocolates, but otherwise, the main focus of the shop appeared to be the retail of wafer cones topped with cool Italian gelato.

I crept downstairs and discovered another world - a space entirely devoted to pick-and-mix chocolates. If you remember the excitement of 'Pick & Mix' from Woolworths in the 1990s, this is the next best thing for adults!

I sought recommendations from a store assistant, who invited me to try a sample. The stifling heat downstairs - even in October - meant that the chocolate had melted to the paper wrapper. Not a great start, but I decided to buy a small selection to review as I enjoyed the flavour of my sample.


Venchi 1878 Pick & Mix Chocolates Review

At £58 per kilogram (or £5.80 per 100g) of chocolates, these weren't particularly cheap. In fact, I netted just eight chocolates for my £7.34. So at nearly £1 a bite, I expected punchy and sublime flavours.

The smallest bag was 36cm in length, perhaps designed to encourage customers to liberally fill it. If you're thinking of giving this as a gift, be warned as eight chocolates inside such a bag looks pathetic. You'll need at least 20-30 chocolates to make it look more acceptable.

Venchi 1878 Pick & Mix Chocolates
My Venchi 1878 Pick & Mix chocolate selection

I deliberately chose a varied assortment - based on shapes, packaging, flavours, and ingredients - to cover all bases, so ended up with:

  1. Cappuccino - Cappuccino flavoured chocolate with extra dark chocolate.
  2. Chocolight Cuor Di Cacao 75% - Extra dark chocolate with sweeteners and no added sugar.
  3. Chocolight Milk Chocolate Prendivoglia - Milk chocolate with hazelnut.
  4. Cremino 1878 - A layer of white chocolate with almond paste between two layers of milk Gianduja made with Piedmont hazelnuts.
  5. Cubotto Chocaviar Crème Brulée - Dark chocolate filled with caramelised sugar and covered with Chocaviar 75%.
  6. Dark Cubotto 85% - Extra dark chocolate.
  7. Gianduiotto - Milk chocolate with hazelnut.
  8. Tiramisù Dark Chocolate - Mascarpone flavoured triple layered praline with coffee and extra-dark chocolate.

Cappuccino

Venchi Cappuccino
Cappuccino

Cappuccino ingredients:
Sugar, cocoa butter, Piedmont hazelnut paste, whole milk powder, cocoa mass, coffee paste (coffee 60%, cocoa butter), cocoa powder, concentrated milk butter, whey powder, coffee powder, emulsifier (soy lecithin), anhydrous milk fat, natural vanilla flavour, natural flavouring.

  • Average weight: 11g

This speckled two-tone chocolate featured a layer of coffee-flecked chocolate atop a milk chocolate base, with a hidden disc of dark chocolate tucked away in the centre.

Inside the Venchi Cappuccino

The aroma was unmistakably that of coffee, and a creamy one at that. There was a slight bitter edge to the coffee but it seemed to pair well with the creaminess in the scent.

Upon tasting, the coffee notes rushed in first, along with a helping of grittiness from the ground coffee within the chocolate. The coffee wasn't overpowering, letting the creamy milk chocolate do its thing by adding sweetness and a creaminess that worked very well. The dark chocolate disc added a gentle bitter tone mid-way, much in the way that you get with the cocoa powder on the top of a cup of cappuccino. A very tasty bite that was sadly over in a flash, but nevertheless, it was a very good start to my selection.


Chocolight Cuor Di Cacao 75%

Venchi Blend Chocolight Cuor Di Cacao 75%
Blend Chocolight Cuor Di Cacao 75%

This square of 75% dark chocolate contained no added sugar, sweetened instead by maltitol, a sugar alcohol used as a sugar substitute. The Venchi website warned of a laxative effect if too many were consumed in a single serving...

Blend Chocolight Cuor Di Cacao 75% ingredients:
Cocoa powder, cocoa butter, cocoa mass, sweetener (maltitol), emulsifier (soy lecithin), natural vanilla flavour.

  • Average weight: 7.5g
  • Typical sugars: 0.3%
Inside the Venchi Blend Chocolight Cuor Di Cacao 75%
My square of dark chocolate had cracked along the middle

This one took a while before any flavour developed, and even then, it was bland and flat. A gentle hit of bitterness was followed by an almost-creamy sweetness which led to the finish. The sweetness remained in the aftertaste, long after the bitterness had curtailed. Throughout though, there was a distinct lack of cacao character - it tasted like dark chocolate but had little defined character.


Chocolight Milk Chocolate Prendivoglia

Venchi Chocolight Milk Chocolate Prendivoglia
Chocolight Milk Chocolate Prendivoglia

Chocolight Milk Chocolate Prendivoglia ingredients:
Sweetener (maltitol), cocoa butter, Piedmont hazelnuts, whole milk powder, cocoa mass, emulsifier (soy lecithin), natural vanilla flavour.

  • Average weight: 17g
  • Typical sugars: 8.8%

Whole hazelnuts in milk chocolate - but with a twist. This too featured Venchi's Chocolight recipe - albeit in milk chocolate - that contained no added sugar, opting for maltitol sweetener instead.

Inside the Venchi Chocolight Milk Chocolate Prendivoglia
Three generous segments await

The aroma was very rich and creamy, although, perhaps unsurprisingly, not very sweet. The bar had a two-tone finish, with shiny chocolate around the base and a matt finish on the domes. Several air bubbles spoilt the otherwise clean appearance.

The whole hazelnut added crunch and flavour, that paired well with the milk chocolate. I found the chocolate creamy yet overly sweet. It had an almost-astringent aftertaste and finished on a very sweet note. Thankfully, the roasted hazelnut flavour helped to tone it down a bit.


Cremino 1878

Venchi Cremino 1878
Cremino 1878

Cremino 1878 ingredients:
Sugar, Cocoa butter, Piedmont hazelnut paste, whole milk powder, almond paste, cocoa mass, whey powder, anhydrous milk fat, emulsifier (soy lecithin), natural vanilla flavour.

  • Average weight: 11g
  • Typical sugars: 40%

Here, a layer of white chocolate was sandwiched between two layers of milk gianduja, resulting in a very soft chocolate. This bite oozed history as it was made to the original 1878 recipe so was a nod to where it all began for Venchi.

Inside the Venchi Cremino 1878
A cube of very soft chocolate that appeared dented along the edges

Hazelnut and milk chocolate are best friends and that was certainly the case here. The aroma was similar to the best chocolate hazelnut spread you could imagine. On tasting, the hazelnut flavour dominated, with chocolate playing a secondary role by adding creaminess and sweetness.

Honestly, the white chocolate was lost against the milk chocolate and hazelnuts but I was okay with that. This chocolate was very rich, unmistakably all about the hazelnuts, and incredibly satisfying. This one was definitely an indulgent sweet treat and one I'd gladly savour over and over again, ideally alongside a fine cup of Italian coffee.


Cubotto Chocaviar Crème Brulée

Venchi Cubotto Chocaviar Crème Brulée
Cubotto Chocaviar Crème Brulée

Cubotto Chocaviar Crème Brulée ingredients:
Sugar, cocoa mass, cocoa butter, glucose syrup, cocoa powder, concentrated milk butter, whole milk powder, water, condensed sweetened whole milk, emulsifier (soy lecithin), natural vanilla flavour.

  • Average weight: 18g
  • Typical sugars: 42%

This bobbled cube boasted an extra-thick chocolate shell - made with both a layer of milk chocolate and a layer of 56% dark chocolate - together with a thick caramel inside, and a coating of tiny 75% dark chocolate pebbles, affectionately branded by Venchi as "Chocaviar".

Inside the Venchi Cubotto Chocaviar Crème Brulée
A chocolate cube liberally covered in dark chocolate 'caviar'

This was a large bite and certainly looked very different. The aroma was that of a bitter dark chocolate that was mildly smokey in nature. the double-depth shell took effort to pierce, releasing a soft-yet-thick, creamy caramel centre.

The dense, creamy caramel added a lot of sweetness but even so, wasn't enough to balance the bitterness from the dark chocolate, and it was this quality that lingered into the aftertaste. Disappointingly, the overall flavour failed to conjure up visions of Crème Brulée in my head.


Dark Cubotto 85%

Venchi Dark Cubotto 85%
Dark Cubotto 85%

Dark Cubotto 85% ingredients:
Cocoa mass, organic Ecuador cocoa mass, sugar, cocoa butter, emulsifier (soy lecithin), natural vanilla flavour.

  • Average weight: 8.5g
  • Typical sugars: 14%

At 85% cocoa content, I expected this to be quite dark and bitter. Venchi reckoned it ought to exhibit an "intense and overwhelming bouquet with slightly toasted, peaty nuances."

Inside the Venchi Dark Cubotto 85%
A smooth finish to the sides with a textured pattern on the top

Indeed, its aroma was forcibly strong, with boisterous smokey, earthy notes emanating from the diminutive cube. The high cocoa content lead to a dry taste, with the smokey notes dominant most of all.

It was bitter and intense, but very little flavour got beyond the smokey front. It is a chocolate that will divide opinion - for some it will be too bitter and too complex to enjoy while others will enjoy its smokiness. Personally, I'd have liked to see a less bitter or more flavourful cocoa used in this recipe.


Gianduiotto

Venchi Gianduiotto
Gianduiotto

Gianduiotto ingredients:
Piedmont hazelnut paste, sugar, whole milk powder, cocoa butter, cocoa mass, anhydrous milk fat, emulsifier (soy lecithin), natural vanilla flavour.

  • Average weight: 8.5g
  • Typical sugars: 36%

This followed neatly on from the Cremino 1878, in that it was another soft chocolate still produced to the original recipe, that contained a 32% minimum of fine Piedmont hazelnut paste.

Inside the Venchi Gianduiotto
Another soft chocolate that looks like it has been battered

Like the Cremino 1878, the Gianduiotto offered up a rich, creamy, nutty aroma and was incredibly soft to bite into, bordering almost on a paste in texture. The flavour of roasted hazelnuts sat at the forefront, with a rush of creaminess and sweetness close behind.

Little flavour was released by the cocoa in the recipe but I was happy with that, as the creaminess, sweetness, and fattiness that was there all helped to elevate the hazelnut taste. The comforting flavour of the Piedmont hazelnuts remained long into the aftertaste. Delizioso!


Tiramisù Dark Chocolate

Venchi Tiramisù Dark Chocolate
Tiramisù Dark Chocolate

I couldn't find the ingredients list or the nutritional information for this chocolate on the Venchi website, although the circular form now looks to now be replaced with a cube version of the same thing.

  • Average weight: 12g

Here sat three layers of coffee paste, mascarpone cream, and extra-dark cocoa, all representing the classic Italian dessert, tiramisù. I love the pudding but how did this tri-toned chocolate compare?

Inside the Venchi Tiramisù Dark Chocolate
A three-layered, slightly bruised chocolate

A strong, bitter coffee fragrance lead in the aroma, with a hint of chocolate and creaminess behind it. The chocolate had quite a soft bite to it, and immediately the coffee sat in centre stage. It was an earthy, bitter coffee flavour that dominated until toward the end when a rush of creaminess kicked in.

Right at the very end there was a sudden glimmer of the bitter dark chocolate. The aftertaste was dominated by the bitter edge of both the coffee and chocolate, each putting up a good fight for supremacy. Overall, this chocolate sat on the bitter side of things and while the flavour was bold and punchy, I'm not sure I would have identified this as 'tiramisù' in a blind taste test.


Overall, I felt this was a very mixed bag of chocolates - literally. Some chocolates, such as the beautifully-packaged Cremino 1878 or the Gianduiotto, were absolutely delicious. Others, such as the Cubotto Chocaviar Crème Brulée or Tiramisù Dark Chocolate, showed so much promise but failed to reveal the flavours I had hoped to taste. I'm also not a fan of the Chocolight variant, although completely understand that this is aimed at a niche segment of the chocolate market.

Venchi 1878 Pick & Mix Chocolates Review

RRP: £5.80 | Venchi 1878 | Shop now

An interesting selection of chocolates, weighted perhaps more towards hazelnuts and coffee. Some flavours were absolutely divine while others were pleasant enough but perhaps not worth the premium I paid.

Packaging
Appearance
Ingredients
Taste
Creativity
Score: 3.4

Should you fancy giving Venchi 1878 chocolates a go, you can buy their assorted chocolates via their website. For the true pick-and-mix experience, you'll need to head to Covent Garden in the capital.

Disclosure: I purchased 108g of assorted chocolates from Venchi 1878 for £7.34. I was not asked for a review. My opinions are my own.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.